Florida’s Property Tax Relief: Is It Time for Public Pensions to Get Off the Investment Roller-Coaster?

By: Russ Kamp, CEO, Ryan ALM, Inc.

Florida voters have spoken, approving a constitutional amendment designed to provide meaningful property tax relief to homeowners. While this may be welcome news for many residents, it raises an important question for Florida’s municipalities and the public pension systems they sponsor. If local governments are going to have fewer financial resources available to fund essential services, including their pension obligations, shouldn’t they be looking for ways to reduce the volatility associated with those obligations? I’ve long argued that defined benefit (DB) pension plans should focus first and foremost on securing the promised benefits, rather than chasing investment returns. That strategy only guarantees volatility of performance, contributions, and funded status. Given the potential impact of property tax reform on municipal budgets, the pursuit of SECURING the promised benefits may be more important than ever.

Think about the financial challenges facing a municipality that experiences declining property tax revenue at the same time its pension portfolio suffers a significant market correction. Not only would the municipality have fewer resources available, but it could also face increasing actuarially determined contributions resulting from investment losses. Talk about a double whammy! Unfortunately, traditional return-focused asset allocation strategies expose pension systems to precisely this possibility. We continue to subject pension plans to the whims of the capital markets, hoping that favorable returns will ultimately offset the inevitable downturns. But what happens when the markets don’t cooperate? Can municipalities afford another prolonged period of underperformance, especially if their revenue-generating capacity has been diminished?

As we’ve discussed many times, there is an alternative to current pension practices that is worth considering. Cash Flow Matching (CFM), provides pension systems with the opportunity to secure a portion of their promised benefits through the carefully matched principal and interest payments of investment-grade bonds. Rather than relying on sales of assets to meet monthly benefit payments, CFM creates a more predictable stream of cash flows designed to meet those monthly obligations when they come due. The objective isn’t necessarily to eliminate return-seeking investments. Instead, it is to secure benefit payments first and then determine how much investment risk is needed to meet future liabilities. Wouldn’t that be a more sensible approach, particularly when municipal budgets may be coming under increasing pressure?

Interestingly, Florida already recognizes the importance of this concept. Florida Statute §112.661(6) addresses the need for sufficient liquidity to meet pension obligations and calls for investment policies to attempt, to the extent possible, to match investment maturities with anticipated cash-flow requirements. Yet how many public pension systems have established dedicated portfolios designed to accomplish that objective? Liquidity management shouldn’t be confused with simply maintaining an allocation to cash or short-term investments. A properly structured CFM portfolio seeks to provide a dependable source of liquidity to meet benefit payments over many years, while reducing the need to liquidate growth assets during unfavorable market environments. Importantly, this strategy can benefit open and closed plans, well-funded and poorly funded plans alike, as every pension system has benefit payments to make, regardless of its funded status or participant demographics.

Of course, CFM doesn’t eliminate every risk facing a pension system. Changes in actuarial assumptions, new benefit accruals, and other factors can still influence liabilities and required contributions. Thank goodness for actuaries! As a result, the CFM strategy is designed to be dynamic and responsive to actuarial adjustments. The degree to which CFM stabilizes funded status and employer contributions depends on how large the allocation is to CFM. However, reducing exposure to market volatility and the sequencing of returns can help create a more predictable funding environment. Isn’t that precisely what municipalities in general and Florida municipalities specifically should be seeking at a time when future revenues may become less certain? Trustees should be asking their investment consultants to demonstrate how their current asset allocation might perform under a significant market decline and then compare those outcomes with a portfolio incorporating meaningful Cash Flow Matching, that will create a bridge over those troubled markets, buying time for the alpha/growth assets to recoup losses.

Florida’s property tax initiative should serve as a wake-up call for public pension trustees, municipal officials, and their investment advisors. The primary objective of a DB pension plan isn’t to outperform a benchmark or generate the highest possible return. It is to ensure that promised retirement benefits are paid when due, at a manageable cost to the plan sponsor. If municipalities face greater uncertainty regarding future revenues, why would we continue to expose their pension systems to unnecessary investment risk without first evaluating alternative investment strategies? Perhaps it is time to get off the performance roller-coaster and embrace a more certain and liability-focused approach to pension management. After all, benefits don’t wait for markets to recover, and neither should pension risk management!