By: Russ Kamp, CEO, Ryan ALM, Inc.
There were significant trade developments announced yesterday between the U.S. and Canada, which don’t seem to be getting the attention that they deserve. I wish that these developments were driven by Canada in retaliation for both the women’s and men’s gold medal performances in Italy, but it seems as if the U.S. is being a sore winner in this situation.
So, what happened yesterday? U.S. under President Trump has reclassified Canada from a Tier 1 allied trading partner to a Tier 3 restricted commerce nation through an executive order. Oh, boy, that sounds onerous. It seems as if this escalation follows tensions brought about by new U.S. tariffs on Canadian goods such as steel, lumber, and energy products prompting Canada to diversify partnerships with China, Mexico, and others. Previously, Canada ranked as the U.S.’s top export market and second-largest trading partner overall, with highly integrated supply chains in autos and energy. The move to tier 3 immediately increases tariffs to 35% on ALL Canadian goods – ouch! Furthermore, this classification places Canada in the same trading bucket as countries such as Belarus and Venezuela.
Not surprisingly, Canada, led by Prime Minister Mark Carney, is countering by pursuing deeper relations with China, Ecuador, Indonesia, and India to reduce U.S. reliance, which still accounts for nearly 70% of its exports. According to various press reports, the White House announced the order approximately two hours before it became public, automatically imposing a 35% tariff on all Canadian goods, financial restrictions, and a freeze on joint military contracts. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney responded within 90 minutes by announcing countermeasures in Parliament, including export controls on critical minerals, such as potash, and withdrawal from NORAD data sharing.
This move is highly disruptive to integrated North American supply chains. The decision followed escalating U.S. tariffs and was defended in Trump’s recent State of the Union address. Canada now faces sharp export declines to its largest market, potentially worsening its trade balance and likely depreciating the Canadian $. Business investment drops due to higher costs for US machinery, leading to layoffs, reduced GDP growth, and sustained inflation from tariff pass-throughs. The potential for retaliatory measures like export controls on minerals will further strain relations between these two long-term allies.
Please don’t think that this development only strikes at Canada’s economy. US consumers and industries will see higher input costs such as steel, which estimates suggest could be as high as $7.5B+, leading to inflation and eroding competitiveness in batteries, clean energy, and defense. Canadian retaliation reduces US exports, impacts GDP, and exacerbates supply chain vulnerabilities with no quick domestic substitutes.
Higher inflation will impact interest rates, leading to higher costs of borrowing, and depending on the significance of these developments could lead to a bear market environment and an economic slowdown concurrent with existing labor force concerns. So, why isn’t this getting more attention?