By: Russ Kamp, CEO, Ryan ALM, Inc

I recently stumbled over a brief article that touched on LDI. I’m always interested in absorbing everything that I can on this subject. I was particularly thrilled when the author stated, “since LDI was recognized as best practice for defined benefit (DB) plans…” – YES! I’m not sure where that proclamation came from, but I agree with the sentiments. The balance of that sentence read, “…sponsors have implemented investment strategies as a journey.”

The initial steps on this journey were for plan sponsors to “simply extend the duration of their fixed income using longer duration market-based benchmarks.” Clearly, the author is referencing duration matching strategies as the LDI product of choice during that phase. According to the author, the next phase in this LDI journey was the use of both credit and Treasuries to better align the portfolio with a plan’s liability risk profile.

Well, we are supposedly entering a third phase in this LDI journey given the improved funded status and “outsized” allocations to fixed income. The question they posed: “How do we diversify the growing fixed income allocation?” Their answer, add a host of non-traditional LDI fixed income products, including private debt and securitized products, to the toolkit to add further yield and return. No, no, and no!

As mentioned previously, funded status/ratios have improved dramatically. According to this report, corporate plans have a funded ratio of 111% at the end of 2024 based on their firm’s Pension Solutions Monitor. Given that level of funding, the only thing that these plans should be doing is engaging a cash flow matching (CFM) strategy to SECURE all the promises that have been given to the plan participants. You’ve WON the pension game. Congratulations! There is no reason for a third phase in the LDI journey. There likely wasn’t a need for the second phase, but that’s water over the dam.

We, at Ryan ALM, believe that CFM is a superior offering within the array of LDI strategies, as it not only provides the necessary liquidity to meet monthly liability cash flows, but it duration matches each and every month of an assignment. Ask us to CFM the next 10 years, we will have 120 duration matches. Most duration matching strategies use either an average duration or a few key rates along the yield curve. Since duration is price sensitive, it changes constantly.  In addition, yield curves do not move in parallel shifts making the management of duration a difficult target.

With CFM you can use STRIPS, Treasuries, investment grade corporates or a combination of these highly liquid assets. You don’t need to introduce less liquid and more complex products. A CFM strategy is all you need to accomplish the pension objective. A CFM strategy provides certainty of the cash flows which is a critical and necessary feature to fully fund liabilities. This feature does not exist in private debt and securitized products. As a reminder, the pension objective is not a return target. It is the securing of the promised benefits at a reasonable cost and with prudent risk. Don’t risk what you’ve achieved. Lock in your funded status and secure the benefits. This strategy is designed as a “sleep well at night” offering. I think that you deserve to sleep like a baby!