By: Russ Kamp, Managing Director, Ryan ALM, Inc.

Milliman has released the results for its Public Pension Funding Index (PPFI), which analyzes data from the nation’s 100 largest public defined benefit plans. They are reporting that the collective funded ratio deteriorated during the last month from 82.8% as of September 30th, to 81.2% as of October 31st, as the combined investments of these plans fell for the first time since April. The estimated return for the PFFI was -1.6%, as losses ranged from -2.9% to -0.6%. The $s lost were roughly $80 billion during the month. The funding deficit now stands at about $1.1 trillion.

You may recall that on November 8th, I produced a blog post titled, “Another Inconsistency”, in which I wrote about Milliman’s reporting of its corporate index that highlighted the fact that the collective funded ratio improved during the month despite asset losses due to the fact that liabilities fell to a great extent as interest rates rose.

I also wrote the following, “what do you think will happen in public fund land? Well, given weak markets, asset levels for Milliman’s public fund index will likely fall” (they did, as reported above). “Given that the discount rate for public pension systems is the ROA, there will be no change in the present value of public pension plans’ future benefit obligations (silly). As a result, instead of witnessing an improvement in the collective funded status of public pensions, we will witness a deterioration.” (and we did!) The inconsistency is startling!

Decisions with regards to benefits and contributions are made all the time based on information related to the funded ratio/status of these pension plans. Using different accounting standards clearly produces different outcomes that might just lead to inappropriate conclusions and the subsequent decisions. Oh, boy!