By: Russ Kamp, CEO, Ryan ALM, Inc.

Anyone who reads this blog knows that we at Ryan ALM, Inc. are huge proponents of defined benefit (DB) plans. We promote the use of DB plans as the only sensible retirement vehicle for the American worker. Blog after blog has discussed ways to secure the benefit promises for those pension plans still operating in the hope that the tide to offloading these critical funds would be slowed, if not stemmed.

When IBM announced that they were going to reopen their plan, I produced the post “Oh, What A Beautiful Morning”, and promised not to sing. I’m also not going to sing today, but I might just shout from the rooftops, if the rain stops in NJ. Why? There is a new DB fund that has just been approved! YES!!

Dee-Ann Burbin, The Associated Press, is reporting that “U.S. meatpacking workers are getting their first new defined benefit pension plan in nearly 40 years under a contract agreement between Brazil-based JBS, one of the world’s largest meat companies, and an American labour union”.

The United Food and Commercial Workers union said 26,000 meatpacking workers at 14 JBS facilities would be eligible for the multi-employer pension plan. “This contract, everything that was achieved, really starts to paint the picture of what everybody would like to have: long-term stable jobs that are a benefit for the employees, a benefit for the employers and a benefit for the community they operate in,” Mark Lauritsen, the head of the UFCW’s meatpacking and food processing division, told the Associated Press in an interview.

In a statement, JBS said the pension plan reflected its commitment to its workforce and the rural communities in which it operates. “We are confident that the significant wage increases over the life of the contracts and the opportunity of a secure retirement through our pension plan will create a better future for the men and women who work with us at JBS.” Lauritsen said DB pension plans used to be standard in the meatpacking industry but were cut in the 1980s as companies consolidated. Big meat companies like Tyson Foods Inc. and Cargill Inc. now offer 401(k) plans but not traditional pensions.

According to Burdin’s article, the union started discussing a return to pensions a few years ago as a way to help companies hang on to their workers. “The good thing about a 401 (k) is that it’s portable, but the bad thing about a 401 (k) is that it’s portable,” he said. “This was a way to capture and retain people who were moving from plant to plant, chasing an extra dime or a quarter”, according to Lauritsen

Workers hailed the plan. “Everything now is very expensive and it’s hard to save money for retirement, so this gives us security,” said Thelma Cruz, a union steward with JBS at a pork plant in Marshalltown, Iowa. A return to DB pension plans is unusual but not unheard of in the private sector. International Business Machines Corp. reopened its frozen pension plan in 2023. Let’s hope that this becomes a trend. As I’ve said many times, asking untrained individuals to fund, manage, and then disburse a “benefit” without disposable income, investment acumen, or a crystal ball is just silly! DB plans help the American worker avoid that trifecta of stumbling blocks!