Cash Flow Matching Versus Duration Matching Liabilities

By: Ron Ryan, CFA, Chairman, Ryan ALM, Inc.

Pension Objective: To fund and SECURE benefits in a cost-efficient manner

Secure Benefits: Only two ways to secure or defease benefits (liabilities):

  1. Insurance Buyout Annuities (IBA)
  2. Cash flow matching

Duration Matching:  Focus is to match the growth rate of liabilities by matching duration

Issues:           

1. Duration matching does NOT fund and does NOT secure benefits

2.  Duration is a PV calculation, so it is very interest rate sensitive

3. Duration changes continuously requiring frequent rebalancing

4.  Generic bond indexes typically used as proxy for liabilities

5.  No generic bond index equals client’s unique liability cash flows

6.  Forced into buying costly Treasury STRIPS after 16 years

7.  Duration is NOT calculated by the actuary

Pros:

1. If you match liability growth rate it avoids actuarial gain/loss

Cash Flow Matching: Focus is to fund each monthly benefit payment with certainty

Issues:           

1. Requires sophisticated modeling skills

Pros:

1. Fully funds and SECURES monthly benefit payment (future values)

2. Reduces risk (future values are not interest rate sensitive)

3. Secures benefits (defeasance) in a cost-efficient manner

4. Skewed to long coupon bonds reduces funding costs

5. Reduces Volatility of Funded Ratio/Funded Status

6. Reduces Funding Costs by about 2% per year

7. Buys time for Alpha assets to perform

8. Matches benefits chronologically

Ryan ALM produced a Chapter in Fabozzi‘s Fixed Income Handbook on Cash Flow Matching vs. Duration Matching.

Leave a Reply