Last week the state Supreme Court of NJ ruled that the Christie administration had the right to reduce / eliminate the annual required contribution (ARC) for the public pension system, based on a constitutionally established practice that the responsibility to allocate public funds is embedded in the budget process. What appears to be a victory for Christie and NJ tax payers couldn’t be further from the truth!
In a pattern that has been repeated for nearly 20 years, one NJ “leader” after another has failed to make the necessary payments to adequately fund public pensions. By not making the full contribution again this year, we are once again kicking the proverbial can down the road.
Remember folks, the benefit that has been promised to our public fund employees is a LIABILITY that must be met. Not funding that liability only makes it more challenging for the pension plan in the long-term, as the plan loses the benefit of compounding returns / interest on each contribution. Just think about the economic impact of not funding the $3.1 billion in 2015, especially if the plan would have earned the state’s presumed return on assets over the next 10-20 years. By deferring that payment, we create a pay as you go system that is much more costly for everyone.
Furthermore, NJ’s pension issue isn’t just a matter of not making the annual required contribution. Why on earth would NJ’s pension officers decide to invest heavily in hedge funds / alternatives at the bottom of the market in 2009? This decision has increased management costs, while returns on the funds have substantially underperformed cheap equity beta. DB plans have a relative objective (liabilities) and not an absolute objective (ROA). Using absolute product in a relative return environment makes little sense.
Our elected officials are kidding themselves If they think that the pension liability is somehow going away. By not appropriately funding the liability now, they are only making it more difficult for the state the future. Think that pensions are taking a big slug of NJ’s budget now, just wait for another 15-20 years.