By: Russ Kamp, Managing Director, Ryan ALM, Inc.

You may recall that 20 days ago in a blog post titled, “Oh, What A Beautiful Morning”, I threatened to break out into song. I didn’t then and I won’t now. You are welcome! However, the gist of my enthusiasm was the announcement that IBM would be converting a 5% company 401(k) match into a 5% contribution into a retirement account that very much sounded like a cash balance plan.

In a recent P&I article, more details of the IBM plan were revealed. As previously known, they are eliminating the company 401(k) match and they will be replacing it with a cash balance component called a “retirement benefit account” (RBA), which is part of the IBM Personal Pension Plan, a defined benefit plan. YES! Details regarding the RBA are available in the 2024 IBM U.S. Benefits Guide.

From the Guide, “All regular employees begin participating in the RBA after one year of service.” “You (the employee) will receive a monthly pay credit that is 5% of your eligible pay, and your balance will grow with interest, which is applied monthly.” The interest rate will be 6% per year through 2026. Beginning in 2027, the interest rate applied to the RBA will be the 10-year US Treasury yield with a minimum of 3% through 2033.

Importantly, unlike the IBM 401(k), one does not have to contribute to be eligible for a RBA contribution. Each employee is eligible after 1 year of service and their benefit vests immediately. The employee has flexibility in what they do with the benefit once they leave IBM, including taking a lump sum, annuitizing the balance, rolling it into the IBM 401(k) plan or into an IRA.

According to the IBM benefits guide, this action is being taken to provide a “stable and predictable benefit that diversifies a retirement portfolio and provides employees greater flexibility.” Furthermore, IBM employees may continue to contribute to the existing 401(k).

Let’s hope that this action by IBM reignites conversations within HR departments on the importance of a defined benefit-like structure as the primary retirement offering. Defined Contribution plans are terrific as supplemental retirement structures, but many American workers are not in a position to fund, manage, and then disburse a benefit through a DC plan. Let us help them realize the American dream of a dignified retirement.